
| Never found |
|
The driller who kept Oak Island’s secret to himself
Part two of four. In 1849 the Truro Company drilled into the money pit and claimed gold, then a pirate flood tunnel. The gold is lost, and the tunnel has never been found.
|
|
James Pitblado ran a drill on Oak Island in the summer of 1849. His boss, Jotham McCully, later wrote that one driller kept his results to himself. In the story told ever since, that driller was Pitblado.
McCully wrote that the driller soon told Charles D. Archibald, of the Londonderry iron mines, what he knew. Then Archibald went to the government for a licence to dig.
The summer’s best find was three small gold links, by McCully’s account. In 2017, one season of The Curse of Oak Island planned $6.53 million of spending in Nova Scotia, in Canadian dollars. The province pledged $1.93 million of it, by its own release.
That money is good news for film crews in Nova Scotia. But the links were lost long ago, so the hunt chases a story that cannot be tested. |

| Sixty years after the Truro crew, a young Franklin Roosevelt and his partners came to dig in 1909. Photo: National Archives. |
|
The legend
Later tellers say the drill passed through two oak chests full of loose metal.
Here is the tale. The Truro crew bored into the money pit with a pod auger, a hand drill used to test for coal. At 98 feet it cut a spruce platform, then oak, then 22 inches of metal in pieces. Three gold links came up on the bit. Tellers say it went through two chests of treasure.
John Gammell, a big shareholder, said he saw Pitblado pocket a find. In 1850 the crew found coconut fibre under the beach at Smith’s Cove. Five stone drains lay below it. So they decided pirates had dug a tunnel to flood the pit, and they built a dam against the tide.
|
|
The evidence
A 1995 dye test by Woods Hole found no direct link from the pit to the sea.
Only one paper survives from 1849, a note giving the crew leave to dig, says the skeptics’ site Critical Enquiry. And it found no record from that time of any find.
So the links rest on McCully’s 1862 letter. He wrote that they were gold and had apparently been “forced from an epaulette,” the fringed shoulder piece on an officer’s coat. The links were never kept.
In 1995, Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution of Massachusetts ran a two-week survey. Its team poured dye into Borehole 10-X, a deep shaft near the pit, and watched the shore. Later, its scientists said they found no direct link to the sea.
The same survey dated two fibre samples, at about 765 and 1,100 years old. Woods Hole called the beach sample’s origin unclear. Then in 2014, the TV show’s own test put fibre from Smith’s Cove between 1260 and 1400.
|
|
What probably happened
Coconut fibre was common ship’s packing, and a carbon date shows when the plant grew.
The pit floods because it is a deep hole on a low island. Woods Hole put the water down to fresh ground water pushing against tidal pressure in the rock. So the flood tunnel was a guess the 1850 crew made to explain natural seepage.
The gold links had no witness outside the crew, and they vanished. And the Pitblado story rests on a letter written 13 years later.
The fibre is the best card believers hold. Coconuts grow nowhere near Nova Scotia, and the dates are old. But ships packed cargo in coconut fibre, and a radiocarbon date tells when the plant grew, not when it reached the beach.
So here is the verdict. The 1850 crew found old packing on a beach and read a pirate’s machine into it.
|
|
What's true
Ten claims. Five are documented. The other five are campfire stories.
Legend
The drill cut through two treasure chests.
Pitblado pocketed a find from the drill.
Pirates built a flood tunnel as a trap.
Five stone drains fed sea water to the pit.
The gold links came off a pirate’s coat.
Evidence
An 1849 note giving leave to dig survives.
McCully’s 1862 letter records three gold links.
Woods Hole’s 1995 dye test found no sea link.
Woods Hole dated fibre to 765 and 1,100 years.
The show’s 2014 test dated fibre to 1260 to 1400.
|
|
Where it is
Any tunnel from Smith’s Cove to the pit would run more than 500 feet.
Smith’s Cove is a small beach on the east end of Oak Island, in Mahone Bay off Nova Scotia’s south shore. Inland from it lies the money pit area. Several Truro men came from Truro and Upper Stewiacke, about 80 miles to the northeast.
|

| The Truro crew lived 77 to 80 miles from Oak Island, about Philadelphia to New York City. Map: Treasure Hunt. |
|
What would settle it
Two labs, blind to each other, testing fibre dug under a permit would settle the dates.
Three steps would settle it. First, dig fibre from untouched beach at Smith’s Cove under a provincial heritage research permit. Record where each piece lay.
Second, split the samples between two labs that never see each other’s results, and publish both. Third, run the 1995 dye test again at the cove, and make the report public.
Until then, the tunnel is a theory and the links are a rumor. But the paper trail goes on. In 1861 a new group, the Oak Island Association, took over the dig.
|
|
Happy Treasure Hunting!
|
|
P.S. Got family from Truro or Upper Stewiacke? Check the attic for an 1849 driller’s letter.
|
|
Sources Liverpool Transcript, 1862, via criticalenquiry.org; Critical Enquiry; Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution, 1995; History; Province of Nova Scotia, 2017; Oak Island Tours; National Archives; Nova Scotia Archives
Send the legend from your town to [email protected] |