
| The craft |
|
John Connor's maps found 370 bottles under a church lawn
A digger in Illinois hoped for 30 relics from an old outhouse pit and got 370 bottles. The free maps that sent him there cover some 12,000 towns.
|
|
One March weekend in Arcola, Illinois, a man watching a dig got so excited he climbed into the pit. Then he dug out a bottle of his own. The dig was John Connor's, behind the Methodist church. Connor has been opening old outhouse pits for 35 to 40 years.
Before trash pickup, the outhouse pit was the family dump. Connor had hoped for maybe 30 relics from this one, a hole 3 feet by 6 feet and 5.5 feet deep. But he got 370 intact bottles from about 1895 to 1910. Several carried the names of old Arcola drugstores.
The key was paper. A local woman, Nancy Rairden, supplied Sanborn fire insurance maps of Arcola from 1887, 1892, 1897, 1907 and 1914. These maps show every building on a block, drawn for insurers pricing fire risk. And laid side by side, they showed the house beside the church changing shape between 1897 and 1907.
Most of those maps are free. The Library of Congress holds about 700,000 sheets covering some 12,000 towns, and its scans are free online. A reprint shop will sell you a printed copy for about $36. |

| Arcola as Sanborn drew it in 1887. Photo: University of Illinois. |
|
The legend
A Sanborn sheet, the tale goes, marks every outhouse with its own symbol.
Diggers like to say every old outhouse is a bank vault. Find the pit, the story goes, and the bottles are waiting.
The second tale is about the maps. A Sanborn sheet, the tale goes, marks every outhouse with its own symbol. So you just walk to the X.
|
|
The evidence
Sanborn maps carry no special mark for a privy.
Daniel Sanborn, a surveyor near Boston, started the company in 1867. The last of its fire maps came out in 1977, when insurers quit using them.
The maps run at 50 feet to the inch. Colors show what a building was made of. Yellow means wood frame and blue means stone. And pink means brick.
In 2017, the Library of Congress began putting its Sanborn sheets online for free. It aimed to post about 500,000.
Sanborn maps carry no special mark for a privy. A digger made that point in the collectors' magazine Bottles and Extras in 2011. So diggers look for small sheds at the back of each lot, then probe the ground.
|
|
What's still down there
A hit on the map can still mean an empty hole.
Thousands of backyard pits, in every one of those 12,000 mapped towns. Most sit under lawns, parking lots and gardens. And most have never been opened.
Here is the method that works. The map cuts a whole block down to two or three small sheds. Then a steel probe finds the soft spot where the pit was filled.
The fair objection is that the map is a lead, not a promise. Some pits were cleaned out years ago, and some privies predate the first map. A hit on the map can still mean an empty hole.
|
|
What's true
Eight claims. Five are documented. Three are campfire stories.
Legend
Any old privy is full of bottles.
Sanborn maps mark every privy with its own symbol.
A bottle digger can dig wherever an old map points.
Evidence
Connor's church dig gave up 370 bottles. The County Chronicle, Illinois.
Sanborn started in 1867. Library of Congress.
The library holds about 700,000 sheets. Library of Congress.
The maps have no privy symbol. Bottles and Extras, 2011.
Connor dug with the church trustees' permission. The County Chronicle.
|
|
Where it is
Chicago is about 155 miles north, a bit farther than New York to Albany.
Arcola is a small town in Douglas County, in east central Illinois. It sits about 30 miles south of Champaign and 14 miles north of Mattoon. Chicago is about 155 miles north, a bit farther than New York to Albany.
|

| St. Louis: 125 miles, about Philly to Washington. Map: Treasure Hunt. |
|
Where to start
Every yard on those maps has an owner today, so get permission first.
Start online. Search loc.gov for your town and the words Sanborn map, and pull every edition. Then compare the earliest sheet with the latest one. A shed that shows up, moves or vanishes is a lead.
Then line the old sheet up with today's view from above. The free site OldInsuranceMaps.net has already pinned many Library of Congress sheets to modern maps.
Then knock on the door. Connor got the church trustees' OK before he dug. Every yard on those maps has an owner today, so get permission first.
|
|
Happy Treasure Hunting!
|
|
P.S. Connor and his wife, Lori, went to Memphis on their 1990 honeymoon. They spent part of it digging bottles.
|
|
Sources The County Chronicle, Illinois, 2026; Library of Congress Sanborn Maps collection; Copyright Lore, July 2017; Bottles and Extras, July 2011; University of Illinois Library; OldInsuranceMaps.net; Hometown History Maps
Send the legend from your town to [email protected] |