
| Treasure found |
|
The letter that started the Oak Island money pit
Part one of four. The famous 1795 dig on Oak Island first reached print in 1857, and the full tale came from a treasure hunter in 1862.
|
|
Jotham McCully dated his letter at Truro, Nova Scotia, on June 2, 1862. In it he told the first full story of the Oak Island money pit. He wrote it 67 years after the dig. And a paper in Liverpool, Nova Scotia, ran it that October.
His story starts in 1795 with three young settlers and their shovels. The bill has grown since then.
In 2018, the TV show The Curse of Oak Island planned to spend $13.46 million in Nova Scotia on one season. That figure is in Canadian dollars. The province pledged $3.97 million of it, by its own news release.
That money is good news for Nova Scotia film crews. But taxpayers may see it another way, because the hole may be a natural sinkhole. And every dollar rests on a tale set down by a man who hunted the treasure himself. |

| Shafts and sheds near the money pit site, August 1931. Photo: Nova Scotia Archives. |
|
The legend
Code breakers later read the stone as two million pounds buried below.
Here is the tale as people tell it today. In 1795 a boy of 16 named Daniel McGinnis found a round dip in the ground on Oak Island. Above it, an old ship’s pulley hung from a sawn-off oak branch. So he came back with two friends, John Smith and Anthony Vaughan, and they dug.
Every ten feet they hit a layer of oak logs. But they quit at 30 feet. About eight years later, a group called the Onslow Company dug to about 90 feet and found a flat stone cut with symbols. Then the pit filled with water. Years after that, code breakers said the symbols meant two million pounds lay buried below.
|
|
The evidence
The stone with symbols first shows up in print in 1862, some 60 years after its supposed find.
The paper trail starts late. On August 8, 1857, the Liverpool Transcript briefly mentioned men digging on Oak Island for the treasure of Captain Kidd, a pirate who died in 1701. A longer piece ran on August 15.
On August 20, 1861, the same paper ran “The Oak Island Folly,” a mocking piece. It said men had dug there nearly every summer for 10 or 12 years.
McCully’s reply, “The Oak Island Diggings,” ran in October 1862. It is the first known account of the stone. Yet McCully also wrote that the Kidd tales began with the first settlers. In January 1864, the British Colonist in Halifax ran a history of the hunt in three parts.
A county history from 1895 tells the tale again, but it is built on the Transcript pieces. So every early version leads back to the men who were digging.
|
|
What probably happened
Retired geologist Steven Aitken calls the money pit a fallen-in cave.
The likeliest answer is a sinkhole. Limestone and gypsum lie under the east end of the island, and gypsum slowly dissolves in water. That leaves caves, and a cave roof can fall in and leave a dip in the ground. In 2020, retired geologist Steven Aitken told CBC, “There is no treasure at the money pit.”
A sinkhole explains the dip, the loose fill and the water. Believers answer with the log layers at neat ten-foot steps. But that detail comes from the 1862 letter, written six decades later by a man in the hunt.
So here is the verdict. Settlers found a sinkhole, dug into soft fill, and hit water. The Kidd story was already going around, and 60 years of retelling did the rest.
|
|
What's true
Ten claims. Five are documented. The other five are campfire stories.
Legend
McGinnis was 16 when he found the dip.
A ship’s pulley hung over the hole.
Oak logs lay every ten feet down.
A stone at 90 feet promised two million pounds.
Captain Kidd buried treasure on the island.
Evidence
Liverpool Transcript, August 8, 1857, notes the Kidd dig.
Liverpool Transcript, August 20, 1861, calls the hunt a folly.
McCully’s letter ran in the Transcript in October 1862.
British Colonist, January 1864, prints a three-part history.
A 2018 Nova Scotia release pledges $3.97 million to the show.
|
|
Where it is
At about 140 acres, Oak Island is roughly 106 football fields of ground.
Oak Island sits in Mahone Bay, off the south shore of Nova Scotia in Canada. Halifax is 37 miles to the northeast, about Baltimore to Washington. A causeway joins the island to the shore at Western Shore, near Chester.
|

| Truro, where McCully wrote, lies 77 miles from Oak Island, about Philadelphia to New York City. Map: Treasure Hunt. |
|
What it takes to go
A provincial treasure licence for Oak Island costs $623 and takes 75 business days.
The island is private. So the only public way on is a guided tour. Tourism Nova Scotia lists a two-hour tram tour from the Oak Island Interpretive Centre at Martin’s Point. It costs $99 an adult and $35 a child, in Canadian dollars. Book ahead.
Leave the detector in the truck. Searching takes a provincial licence under the Oak Island Treasure Act of 2010. It costs $623, needs a heritage permit and the owner’s written consent, and takes 75 business days.
To read the paper yourself, criticalenquiry.org posts a copy of McCully’s 1862 letter. From there the next firm step in the record waits. It is McCully’s own crew from Truro, digging most summers from about 1850.
|
|
Happy Treasure Hunting!
|
|
P.S. McCully’s letter turns 164 this year. Men are still digging where it pointed.
|
|
Sources Liverpool Transcript via criticalenquiry.org; British Colonist, 1864; Province of Nova Scotia, 2018; CBC, 2020; Tourism Nova Scotia; Nova Scotia Legislature; Nova Scotia Archives; Wikipedia
Send the legend from your town to [email protected] |